← All posts
SOC 1 vs SOC 2SOC 1 or SOC 2SOC 2 for startupsSOC 1 for SaaS

SOC 1 vs SOC 2 for Startups: Which Report Does Your Customer Need?

Choose between SOC 1 and SOC 2 by checking whether your service affects a customer's financial reporting or whether the request concerns security and related controls.

The report choice starts with how the customer uses the service and which control question its reviewer needs answered.
The report choice starts with how the customer uses the service and which control question its reviewer needs answered.

SOC 1 and SOC 2 answer different questions about a service provider. If your service’s controls may affect a customer’s internal control over financial reporting, ask whether its financial statement auditor needs a SOC 1 report. If the request is about security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, or privacy, ask whether the customer needs SOC 2. Get the answer from the person who will use the report before you pick a CPA engagement. The type of data you store does not settle the choice by itself.

SOC 1 vs SOC 2: what does each report cover?

The AICPA defines SOC 1 as an examination of service-organization controls likely relevant to user entities’ internal control over financial reporting. It says SOC 1 reports serve those customers and the CPAs who audit their financial statements. That focus is often shortened to ICFR.

The AICPA’s SOC 2 guide describes an examination of a service organization’s system and controls relevant to Security, Availability, Processing Integrity, Confidentiality, or Privacy. The selected Trust Services Criteria and the service description shape the report. A qualified CPA firm performs the independent examination and issues either kind of SOC report.

Question SOC 1 SOC 2
Why does the report user need it? To assess service controls relevant to its financial reporting. To understand controls for the selected Trust Services Criteria.
Who commonly uses it? The customer and its financial statement auditor. Customers and other intended users reviewing the service and its controls.
What shapes the scope? The service and control objectives relevant to the customer’s financial reporting. The described system, service commitments, system requirements, and selected criteria.
Is it Type 1 or Type 2? Either type can apply. Either type can apply.

The SOC number is about purpose. The Type number changes the control question and time boundary. The AICPA explains that a Type 1 report examines control design as of a specified date, while a Type 2 report also examines operating effectiveness over a specified period. See the Type 1 versus Type 2 guide after the report purpose is clear.

Does handling financial data mean you need SOC 1?

No automatic rule follows from a field name or data category. Ask what the service does in the customer’s process. Consider a hypothetical billing tool: if a customer uses its output to record revenue, the customer and its auditor may need information about controls over transaction processing and reports. If an analytics tool merely displays financial figures that the customer independently reconciles from another authoritative system, its role may be different. The customer and its auditor must assess their own financial reporting reliance; your startup should not guess on their behalf.

Map the flow before asking for a quote:

  1. What transactions, balances, or reports does your service create, change, transmit, or retain?
  2. Which output does the customer use in its accounting or reporting process?
  3. Can the customer change or verify that output outside your service?
  4. Which controls at your company affect the completeness, accuracy, or authorization of that output?
  5. What exact report does the customer or its auditor request, and for which entity, service, date or period?

These questions help define a discussion with the report user and CPA firm. They are not a test that declares your company subject to SOC 1.

Can one report answer both requests?

Do not promise that one report replaces the other. A SOC 1 report focused on financial reporting may leave a customer’s security review unanswered. A SOC 2 report may provide useful control information but still lack the scope or detail its financial statement auditor needs.

There is a nuance: the AICPA has published an interpretation on a user auditor’s use of a SOC 2 report in a financial statement audit. That does not turn every SOC 2 report into SOC 1. The user auditor decides whether and how the available report helps with its procedures. Ask that auditor or the customer’s audit owner instead of telling sales that the reports are interchangeable.

A startup can also need both reports if different users ask different questions. Shared source records, such as access changes, release reviews, or incident response, may support both engagements. The scopes, objectives, management descriptions, evidence requests, and CPA conclusions still need separate review. Do not assume a control approved for one report proves the claims in the other.

What should you ask before engaging a CPA firm?

Start with the customer-request guide if the ask arrived through procurement. Send a short set of questions to the person who will accept the report:

  • Is the request tied to your financial statement audit or to a security and vendor review?
  • Do you need SOC 1, SOC 2, or both? Will another form of review work while the report is pending?
  • Which product, entity, transactions, system, and controls must be covered?
  • Do you require Type 1 or Type 2, and which date or period matters?
  • Who can confirm that the final scope will satisfy the request?

Record the answer and its owner. Do not copy confidential deal terms or customer financial data into a Git repository just to track the decision. Take the bounded request and a diagram of the service to a qualified CPA firm. The firm can help plan the examination, but the customer or its auditor still decides what meets its need.

Where FileGRC fits

FileGRC is a Git-native GRC workspace for SOC 2 work. JSON holds structured records, Markdown holds long-form work, and Git supplies the change history. It helps a team connect SOC 2 scope, policies, controls, recurring work, and evidence references after the report decision is made. Starter records are proposals, not compliance claims.

FileGRC does not prepare a SOC 1 engagement or replace source systems. It does not operate your controls, perform either examination, decide whether evidence is sufficient, or issue a report. Use the startup SOC 2 guide if the confirmed need is SOC 2. If the buyer needs SOC 1, work with a qualified CPA firm on that engagement’s scope and records rather than treating the SOC 2 starter as a SOC 1 program.

Open source · MIT

Run your SOC 2 program as files in Git.

Keep policies, controls, work, and evidence indexes in a repository your team and agents can inspect. Add optional FileGRC Autopilot email and Slack reminders to keep work moving.

Frequently asked questions

What is the main difference between SOC 1 and SOC 2?

SOC 1 addresses controls at a service organization that are likely relevant to a customer's internal control over financial reporting. SOC 2 examines the described service system and controls relevant to the selected Trust Services Criteria, such as Security. Ask the report user which question it needs answered.

Does a SaaS company need SOC 1 if it handles financial data?

Handling financial data alone does not decide. The question is whether the service and its controls are likely relevant to the customer's internal control over financial reporting. Ask the customer and, when applicable, its financial statement auditor to identify the process, report, and scope they need.

Can a SOC 2 report replace a SOC 1 report?

Do not assume it can. The AICPA has issued guidance on when a user auditor may use a SOC 2 report in a financial statement audit, so the answer depends on that auditor's procedures and the report's scope. Get the report user's answer before promising one report in place of the other.

Can a startup need both SOC 1 and SOC 2?

Yes, if customers or their auditors need both financial-reporting control information and a separate report on security or other Trust Services Criteria. Confirm each request, service scope, report type, and timing with the users and qualified CPA firms before planning two engagements.

Is SOC 1 Type 2 the same as SOC 2 Type 1?

No. The number after SOC identifies the report's purpose. Type 1 examines control design as of a specified date; Type 2 also examines operating effectiveness over a specified period. Decide SOC 1 versus SOC 2 first, then ask which type the report user needs.

Does FileGRC prepare a SOC 1 report?

No. FileGRC is a Git-native GRC workspace for SOC 2 work. It organizes management's structured records, long-form work, and evidence references, but does not perform either examination or issue either report. A qualified CPA firm and the report users set the SOC 1 engagement requirements.